What is this about?

This blog is focused on providing information on Pay As You Drive car insurance in Australia. If you find any information, papers, news articles or websites that we should add, please let us know!

Sunday, April 20, 2008

Freakonomics

Not-So-Free Ride

By STEPHEN J. DUBNER and STEVEN D. LEVITT

Published: April 20, 2008, in the Green Issue of the New York Times Magazine

The trouble with negative externalities

Americans drive too much. This isn't a political or moral argument; it's an economic one. How so?

Because there are all sorts of costs associated with driving that the actual driver doesn't pay. Such a condition is known to economists as a negative externality: the behavior of Person A (we'll call him Arthur) damages the welfare of Person Z (Zelda), but Zelda has no control over Arthur's actions. If Arthur feels like driving an extra 50 miles today, he doesn't need to ask Zelda; he just hops in the car and goes. And because Arthur doesn't pay the true costs of his driving, he drives too much.

What are the negative externalities of driving? To name just three: congestion, carbon emissions and traffic accidents. Every time Arthur gets in a car, it becomes more likely that Zelda — and millions of others — will suffer in each of those areas.

Which of these externalities is the most costly to U.S. society? According to current estimates, carbon emissions from driving impose a societal cost of about $20 billion a year. That sounds like an awful lot until you consider congestion: a Texas Transportation Institute study found that wasted fuel and lost productivity due to congestion cost us $78 billion a year. The damage to people and property from auto accidents, meanwhile, is by far the worst. In a 2006 paper, the economists Aaron Edlin and Pinar Karaca-Mandic argued that accidents impose a true unpaid cost of about $220 billion a year. (And that's even though the accident rate has fallen significantly over the past 10 years, from 2.72 accidents per million miles driven to 1.98 per million; overall miles driven, however, keep rising.) So, with roughly three trillion miles driven each year producing more than $300 billion in externality costs, drivers should probably be taxed at least an extra 10 cents per mile if we want them to pay the full societal cost of their driving.

How can this be achieved? Higher tolls, especially variable tolls like congestion pricing, are one option. This seems to have worked well in London but was recently quashed in New York City, where the political hurdles proved too high.

A higher gas tax might also work. If a typical car gets 20 miles to the gallon, then the proper tax would be about $2 per gallon. But with the current high market price for gas and the political hysterics attached to it — well, good luck with that one.

This brings us to automobile insurance. While economists may argue that gas is poorly priced, that imbalance can't compare with how poorly insurance is priced. Imagine that Arthur and Zelda live in the same city and occupy the same insurance risk pool but that Arthur drives 30,000 miles a year while Zelda drives just 3,000. Under the current system, Zelda probably pays the same amount for insurance as Arthur.

While some insurance companies do offer a small discount for driving less — usually based on self-reporting, which has an obvious shortcoming — U.S. auto insurance is generally an all-you-can-eat affair. Which means that the 27,000 more miles than Zelda that Arthur drives don't cost him a penny, even as each mile produces externalities for everyone. It also means that low-mileage drivers like Zelda subsidize high-mileage drivers like Arthur.

Aaron Edlin first noticed this imbalance more than 15 years ago. "I was a graduate student at Stanford," he says, "and I drove maybe 2,000 miles a year. But I paid roughly the same $1,000 as if I'd driven 10 times as much, which was a huge portion of my budget." A few years later, Edlin was serving on the President's Council of Economic Advisers when he floated an idea that economists had long found attractive: pay-as-you-drive (PAYD) insurance. It seemed like an obvious solution. Since no one expects to pay the same price for, say, a 60-minute massage as they pay for a 15-minute massage, why should people pay the same for insurance no matter how many miles they drove?

"The objection within the White House," Edlin recalls, "was there wasn't good academic research on the subject."

Edlin and a few others, including Jason Bordoff and Pascal Noel at the Brookings Institution, have since done such research. It makes a compelling case that PAYD insurance would work well, reducing the carbon emissions, congestion and accident risk created by too much driving while leading drivers to pay the true cost of their mileage. Bordoff and Noel put the total social benefit at $52 billion a year.

The better news is that PAYD insurance is no longer just an academic exercise. G.M.A.C. has begun using OnStar technology to offer mileage discounts, and next month Progressive will roll out a comprehensive PAYD plan called MyRate. Progressive, the huge Ohio-based insurer that has long prided itself as an innovator, will first offer the plan in six states, having run a similar pilot in three other states. Drivers who sign up for MyRate will install a small wireless device in their cars that transmits to Progressive not just how many miles they drive but also when those miles are driven and, to some extent, how they are driven: the device measures the car's speed every second, from which Progressive can derive acceleration and braking behavior. Which means that Progressive will not only be able to charge drivers for the actual miles they consume but will also better assess the true risk of each driver.
If PAYD is such a great idea, why has it taken so long? There are at least three reasons: the tracking technology has only recently become affordable; insurers were anxious about drivers' privacy concerns; and there was a substantial risk for whichever company was first to offer PAYD on a large scale.

Participation in the MyRate program is voluntary, and that's where the economics get interesting. As with most incentive changes, there will be winners and losers. The clearest winners are people like Zelda, who can drive the same distance they used to drive and pay less. What's less obvious is whether Progressive will be a winner; there are, in fact, a couple of situations in which Progressive could lose out. If all MyRate accomplishes is to give Progressive's low-mileage customers the rate cut they deserve, then Progressive is doing little more than lowering its own revenues. It could, of course, try to compensate by raising rates on all its high-mileage Arthurs, but then there's nothing to stop Arthur from buying his insurance elsewhere. (Of course, losing its riskiest customers to other companies might also prove profitable for Progressive.)

If, however, Progressive can corner the Zelda market by stealing millions of Zeldas from other insurers, then it could make a killing by being the first to sell accurately priced insurance for low-mileage drivers. The bigger goal for society — and the wild card in this or any incentive shift — is to create real behavior change. And that is always easier said than done. But if Progressive's PAYD insurance can induce some of its high-mileage customers to drive less and especially to drive more safely, resulting in smaller claims payouts for Progressive and fewer negative externalities for everyone, then it could truly be a win-win-win situation.

Except, perhaps, for Progressive's rivals.

Saturday, September 1, 2007

Salvador Minguijón Pérez on PAYD

Dear Ladies and Gentlemen,
 
David McClure Director of telematics in Research and Markets exposed in its last report on the branch tendencies: 
 
"We have witnessed a dramatic change in the telematics industry in recent years, with the initial dominance of vehicle manufacturers being replaced by the business needs and policy objectives of the insurance industry and European governments.
"But in order for them to realise their goals, we need to see a step-change from the current situation, where each telematics service requires different in-car hardware, to a point where all applications can be supported on a single platform. This will require major investment and at present, none of the principle stakeholders appears willing to make the commitment alone, each preferring to 'piggyback' their services off a system installed at someone else's expense.
"Our report clearly illustrates the benefits that can be achieved once the present impasse is resolved."
 
Refering to the project "Pay as you drive" I fully coincide with the diagnosis of David Mcclure, it is a reality that I usually have to face with in the negotiations for the exploitation of the patent EP 0700009.
 
Currently, IP Auctions GmbH (Germany) is entrusted with the conduct of negotiations with interested parties in Europe. The final bidding phase will be brought to termination on October 31st. More information at www . ip-auction .eu

A fact that can break this situation is the acquisition of Tele Atlas by TomTom. We had recently commented that TomTom had acquired the centre of development of Siemens-VDO in Einhoven, and with it, the whole telematic technology of Siemens-VDO.
 
But, besides the development plans of TomTom in this field, we will also have to pay atention to the reaction of their competitors Navman, Mio, Garmin, etc that will tend to articulate around Navteq. That, on the other hand, will see in danger its up to now comfortable leadership in the business applications market.
 
For most of the insurance companies, it would be great if a company like TomTom or Navteq took the leadership in the offer of a platform that supports an application "Pay as you drive" together with other telematics solutions.
 
Nevertheless, there are some companies and people that, for one or another reason, are carrying out big efforts to overcome this impasse, for example:

At first place we have Norwich Union whose objective is to become the leader in the automobile insurance in England, and that supports its project with a set of additional services offered by RAC and Trafficmaster.
 
Octotelematics, that has worked with its own system of localization of vehicles to get a great penetration in the insurance companies. It has a platform that is gradually turning to be as a "Pay as you drive" system. It is nowadays a business model for Spanish, French or American companies, an other countries where the problem of robbery is much more important.
 
It is necessary to name Todd Alexander Litman in Canada and Ian Parry and Allen Greenberg in U.S.A who are taking several years trying that their respective governments force the insurance companies to offer policies linked to the use. This is a topic that we will discuss later on, because it deserves a specific article.
 
We should also mention to the family Cobopoulos, which is determinated in developing a telematic project in the city of Athens that would be a world reference and that would incorporate, among other multiple services, the "Pay as you drive" Insurance.
 
We should not forget that Fotis Karamitsos, the godfather of the telematics in Europa, is Greek and that he has a great influence in his country. It is hoped that Greece reaches a great economic dynamism in next years. The traffic supposes a tremendous problem in this country already. So everything indicates that indeed Greece can play an important part in the development of the European telematics systems.
 
In my previous bulletin of June, I made the error of linking the activities of Detecon and T-Systems, when in fact Detecon is a completely independent consultancy. They advise their clients with the best possible solutions for their business and are not bounded in any way to solutions offered by its shareholder T-Systems. Certainly, and without any doubt, a partner that any European insurance company that wants to throw a project "Pay as you drive", should speak with.

As always, I have upgraded my " Pay As You Drive Directory" and my News Bulletin.

If somebody wants that their address is erased of my distribution list, please return me this message with the word "DELETE."

Yours sincerelly.
 
Salvador Minguijón Pérez.
Interim Management.
+ 34 649 49 17 70
+ 34 976 59 58 71
Email: s.minguijon@salvador-minguijon.es
Web: http://www.salvador-minguijon.es

Friday, August 24, 2007

News from Todd Litman

Here are news items concerning Pay-As-You-Drive pricing:

Ian Ayres and Barry Nalebuff (2007), "Would You Buy Car Insurance By The Mile?, Forbes.com ( http://moneycentral.msn.com/content/Insurance/P45802.asp). This article by two Harvard economists highlights the economic justification for PAYD.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The National Motorists Association's "NMA's Position on Auto Insurance" ( http://www.motorists.org/insurance ) indicates that many motorists support PAYD insurance pricing.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Salvador Minguijon's "Pay_as_you_drive Blog" ( http://payasyoudrive.wordpress.com ) provides updates on various issues related to PAYD insurance.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Below is a letter I sent to CEO of the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC), our provincial insurance agency. British Columbia has a special opportunity to implement PAYD vehicle insurance and registration fees because ICBC insures and registers all vehicles in the province. PAYD would help achieve many of ICBC's stated goals, including increasing insurance affordability and equity, reducing traffic deaths and accident costs, and responding to consumers. In recent years a number of organizations have asked ICBC to offer PAYD pricing, or at least to implement a pilot project to test the concept.
 
The British Columbia government recently established one of North America's most aggressive climate change emission reduction targets (emissions 10% below 1990 levels by 2020) and appointed a special Climate Change Secretariat to identify potential emission reduction strategies. Each government agency is required to recommend emission reduction strategies. This is an opportunity for ICBC to show international leadership with insurance pricing innovation. However, despite several requests, ICBC has not indicated its position on PAYD pricing or whether this will be included in its submission to the Secretariat.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Paul Taylor
President and Chief Executive Officer
Insurance Corporation of British Columbia
151 West Esplanade
North Vancouver, BC V7M 3H9
15 August 2007

Dear Mr. Taylor,
I am writing once again to ask for ICBC's policy on Pay-As-You-Drive (PAYD) pricing, and specifically whether this strategy will be included in ICBC's submission to the BC Climate Change Secretariat. I made this request twice before during the last month and have so far received no reply.
 
Research by myself and others indicates that PAYD pricing could provide significant benefits to motorists and other road users; it can help achieve ICBC's stated goals to increase insurance affordability and road safety; and it can be implemented with minimal risk by starting with a pilot project.
 
I believe that, as people learn more about Pay-As-You-Drive they will agree that it should be considered as a climate change emission reduction strategy, and that ICBC should quickly implement a pilot project to test the concept. I therefore ask you:

  • To provide ICBC's official policy on PAYD pricing.
  • To share the results of ICBC's research on PAYD pricing.
  • To include PAYD in ICBC's submission to the BC Climate Change Secretariat.
  • To quickly implement an odometer-based PAYD pilot project to test the concept.
  • To explain any objections ICBC has to this concept.

Our Institute will soon begin a multi-media campaign to educate people about PAYD pricing and build support for its implementation in BC. It would be best for everybody if this is a cooperative effort between our organizations. I would like to meet with you to discuss this.

Sincerely,
Todd Alexander Litman
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Attached is a backgrounder which provides additional information about PAYD in British Columbia. Please let me know if you have comments or questions about this.

Sincerely,
Todd Alexander Litman
Victoria Transport Policy Institute (www.vtpi.org)
litman@vtpi.org
Phone & Fax 250-360-1560
1250 Rudlin Street, Victoria, BC, V8V 3R7, CANADA
"Efficiency - Equity - Clarity"

Wednesday, April 4, 2007

Salvador Minguijon Perez on PAYD

Dear Ladies and Gentlemen:

There has been a lot of activity in Germany with regard to the project "Pay as you drive" during this month. 

I try to look for the English versions of the documents that I use in my references, but this is not always possible. Although I suppose that it is better to have located this documentation in German than to ignore it.  

The most important news is that there is an agreement between IBM and Allianz to develop the project at European level .

We all know that IBM has been working for years in this project and that its collaboration first with Norwich and later on with Cert, has allowed him to dedicate a very superior quantity of resources than the rest of its competitors. However, the sudden interest of Allianz in this project has surprised me.

Also with European objectives we have the projects of Siemens
with Zürich Versicherung and T-System
with WGV . All with the enough capacity to develop this project. 

A special case is Swiss-Re that, together with Norwich Union, are the insurance companies with more motivation in this project and this compensates in great way its difficulty to manage technical projects.  

I imagine that Axa-Winterthur, eternal competitor of Allianz, will redefine his strategy with regard to this project immediately, in fact their North American branch Unigard has thrown an investigation project with a budget of 6 million dollars, a third of which are federal founds.

I suppose that these companies will establish one or two projects at European level, which will be the ones that definitely will be implanted. The rest of the companies, with local project, such as Sara , Unipol, Uniqa and Huk-Corbug will finish adding to these projects.  

In great way, what will happen depends on the result of the auction of the patent EP0700009 that is something like a ticket to be able to participate in this project. This ticket allows you to ascend to this train, called PAYD, but you have to make the effort of being in the station, at the correct time and in the correct train. In this train there are few seats, so if you don't have ticket, you will have to fight to go up to it, and have luck, because many travelers will stay in the station.

It doesn't seem that Norwich has any intention of informing us of how its project is developing. We can only sense it for the euphoric presentation of results of its supplier Trafficmaster, not bad if we remind that the project began commercially in September of 2006. 

Regarding Progressive's Tripsense project in USA, has announced to wide their tests to the states of Michigan and Oregon, it is necessary to remember that he has already made some small tests in Minnesota, using very low cost equipment, with open software and that doesn't need installation. It is the most economic way to make some tests, although if the project gets in a commercial phase, a more specific equipment would be designed.

There are new informative publications of the project that have a great interest:

http://www.ptv.de/download/mobility/hintergruende/PayAsYouDrive.pdf


http://www.sbd.co.uk/assets/Future_Trends_NEWS_release.doc

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAYD

http://www.vtpi.org/dbvi.pdf

http://www.ivw.unisg.ch/org/ivw/web.nsf/SysWebRessources/FT4-Helvetia/$FILE/Helvetia.pdf


http://www.lexisnexis.de/aktuelles/112115?or=13&ur=0&tt=news


http://www.businessportal24.com/de/Kfz_Versicherer_Verdraengungswettbewerb_Massnahmenbuendel_Marktposition_158341.html


http://payasyoudrive.wordpress.com/2007/03/22/the-endless-crisis-in-the-automobile-insurance/


 
It is also interesting the
publication of the University of Cambridge that list projects that are linked with this in great way, the interest raised in the sector of rent-a-car, in companies
of services
, technology
or countries like Korea or India
.
 
I have upgraded my database Pay as you drive directory .

If somebody wants that their address is erased of my distribution list, please return me this message with the word "DELETE."
 
Yours sincerelly.
Salvador Minguijon Perez. 

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Salvador Minguijon Perez on PAYD, including Michael Hawker from IAG

Dear Ladies and Gentlemen:

The Victoria Transport Policy Institute has revised the document Pay-As-You-Drive Vehicle Insurance, which is without any doubt the most complete study that exists on this topic and, of course, I recommend reading it again.  

Insurance Australia Group (IAG) chief executive Michael Hawker, exposes his vision about this project
that is not very different from what we had already exposed in the article Strategic Positioning of the Insurance Companies regarding the projects "Pay As You Drive".

If a month ago I underlined the errors of Wikipedia relating to the Patent EP0700009, this month I take back because the information that is in the epigraph Insurance Patent is concise and correct. When trying to look for the person that has published this information I found NOWA. I suppose that in fact it will be Marc Nowotarski, one of the few specialists in the application of patents in the sector of the insurance.  

Such as I advanced last month, the rights of the European patent that are still of my property, that is to say in Italy, Spain, France and Germany, although in the last three countries there is granted an nonexclusive license, will be jointly auctioned next day May 15 in Munich by the company IP Auctions GmbH . It is still possible that some country is retired of the auction.

The auction of the patent has some very concrete motivations , but I am convinced that will favour the development of this project. Some great insurance company has manifested a certain relief, because they thought that the property of the patent would pass to a great technological company and that consequently it could not be used aggressively by their competitors. I am not so sure of this, the range of companies that are looking at this project is very wide and with very different interests .

Besides
the interests of the insurance own companies (in Europe) and of the users (in United States), there are two problems of great importance pushing this project, one of them is the congestion of the traffic and the other one the climatic change . For instance, it doesn't seem that nobody worries too much of the 30,000 annual deaths that originates the traffic in Europe.  

Regarding the first one, I believe that Tony Blair's answer to the popular rejection to the project Road Charge represents the position of all the governments of the industrialized and democratic countries, in opinion of some, too fearful of losing votes.  

But contrarily to what is usually thought, it is not that the public transportations absorb the decrease of the private traffic
, that would be practically impossible, but of conjugating this with a smaller use of the vehicle, something that will have many repercussions in the organization and forms of life of our cities.  

If some wants to deepen more in the topic of the congestion of the traffic, I recommend you the following mail list http://lists.umn.edu/cgi-bin/wa?A0=con-pric .

           I have upgraded my database Pay as you drive directory .
            If somebody wants that their address is erased of my distribution list, please return me this message with the word "DELETE."
 
Yours sincerely.
Salvador Minguijon Perez.